圍攻希法醫院
圍攻希法醫院 [1][2] | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
加沙圍城戰的一部分 | |||||||
包圍示意圖 | |||||||
|
希法醫院是加薩走廊最大的醫療中心,2023年11月以色列—哈瑪斯戰爭期間,以色列稱希法醫院內藏有哈瑪斯的指揮部而將其包圍。11月11日,希法醫院被以色列軍隊完全包圍,與外界切斷聯繫,加薩衛生部指當時院內有約1500名病人、1500名醫護人員以及15000名在院內避難的難民[10][11]。以色列與美國聲稱醫院地下藏有哈瑪斯的指揮中心,哈瑪斯與醫院方均否認此事[12][13],院方並邀請國際社會派遣安全人員入院搜查以反駁以色列指控[14]。
11月15日,以色列軍隊進入希法醫院,並表示確實在院內發現了哈瑪斯的指揮部[15]。BBC與CNN等媒體均發現以色列軍方發布的影片內容前後不自洽,且疑似有剪接痕跡[16][17],多家媒體指以色列發布的資訊不準確或經過變造[18][19]。11月22日以色列發布影片指醫院地下發現多條地道[20],《華爾街日報》與《衛報》皆指此與以方最早聲稱的「醫院中有指揮部」不符[21][22]。以色列又公布醫院閉路電視錄像,顯示有兩名己方人質被帶入醫院中[23]。12月21日,《華盛頓郵報》分析指出以方公布的地道實際上並不與醫院相連[24]。2024年1月2日,美國發布機密文件顯示希法醫院曾被用作哈馬斯指揮中心[25],隔日以色列又稱成功摧毀醫院下的一條地道[26],但有媒體反駁指此兩者皆不能作為醫院被用作軍事用途的確鑿證據[27][28]。11月24日,以色列軍隊在雙方達成暫時停火協議後撤出希法醫院[8]。
以色列對醫院的進攻與未能發現醫院的軍事設施都招致大量批評[29][30][31][32],聯合國人權事務高級專員辦事處專員福爾克爾·蒂爾克呼籲對此事展開獨立調查[33]。國際法規定交戰雙方只有在醫院被用作軍事用途,且對己方帶來傷害時才能將其作為攻擊目標[34]。以色列被控以資訊戰以開脫自己攻擊醫院、違反國際法的責任,希法醫院的醫護人員也指以色列的攻擊直接造成院中新生兒等病患的死亡[35]。世界衛生組織秘書長譚德塞表示「醫院不是戰場,以色列的行為完全無法令人接受」[36]。
2024年3月18日,以色列方面以希法醫院內存在哈馬斯領導人為由襲擊希法醫院,[37]以色列方面表示此次進攻造成1名以色列士兵死亡,20名巴勒斯坦武裝分子死亡。[38][39]
2024年3月20日,以色列國防軍表示其繼續在希法醫院開展軍事行動,而且已擊斃90名武裝人員並逮捕160人。[40][41]3月21日,以色列國防軍又宣布在希法醫院打死50名武裝人員,以方在該醫院打死的哈馬斯武裝人員總數達到140人,後來又改口稱打死170人、200人。[42][43][44]以色列還命令巴勒斯坦人撤離希法醫院。[45]哈馬斯則表示在過去的幾小時內,以軍對希法醫院的襲擊已導致13名病人死亡。[46]多名患者因缺乏醫療用品而死亡。[47]世界衛生組織總幹事譚德塞表示,自以色列襲擊希法醫院以來,世衛組織已經和希法醫院失去聯繫。[48]哈馬斯和傑哈德表示,他們的確在希法醫院附近和以色列軍隊作戰。[43]3月30日,以色列軍方表示在希法醫院的軍事行動中打死了兩名哈馬斯高級領導人。[49]4月1日,以色列軍方宣布,以軍部隊已完成在希法醫院一帶的作戰活動,並撤離了醫院範圍。加沙衛生部表示,以軍撤離前放火燒毀希法醫院建築物,導致醫院完全停運;醫院內和周圍發現了數十具屍體,其中一些已經腐爛。[5]世界衛生組織同樣表示,以色列軍隊對希法醫院的圍攻已摧毀該醫院。[50]
參考文獻
- ^ Fuller, Thomas; Boxerman, Aaron; Browne, Malachy; Collier, Neil. Gaza City Hospitals Are Caught in Deadly Crossfire. The New York Times. 10 November 2023 [15 November 2023]. (原始內容存檔於15 November 2023) –透過NYTimes.com.
- ^ Vega, Luis de. Crisis in Gaza's largest hospital: 'We need to evacuate now, but they shoot everyone who tries to escape'. EL PAÍS English. 11 November 2023 [19 November 2023]. (原始內容存檔於19 November 2023).
- ^ Sanz, Juan Carlos. Siege by Israeli army forces excavation of mass grave in Gaza's main hospital. EL PAÍS English. 15 November 2023 [15 November 2023]. (原始內容存檔於15 November 2023).
- ^ England, Andrew; Zilber, Neri. Israel raids Gaza’s biggest hospital. Financial Times. 2024-03-18 [2024-03-22]. (原始內容存檔於2024-03-20).
- ^ 5.0 5.1 5.2 以军结束突袭行动撤离 希法医院发现多具尸体. 聯合早報. 2024-04-01 [2024-04-02]. (原始內容存檔於2024-04-13) (中文).
- ^ England, Andrew; Chazan, Guy; Seleh, Heba; Srivastava, Mehul; Khaled, Mai. Israeli military raids Gaza's largest hospital in climax of siege. Financial Times. 15 November 2023 [22 November 2023]. (原始內容存檔於20 November 2023).
- ^ Israeli troops enter Gaza's Al-Shifa Hospital in culmination of siege. The Straits Times. 15 November 2023 [22 November 2023]. (原始內容存檔於22 November 2023).
- ^ 8.0 8.1 Israeli army withdraws from Gaza hospital after truce: Hamas ministry =24 November 2023. Economic times. [24 November 2023]. (原始內容存檔於24 November 2023).
- ^ Presse, AFP - Agence France. Fighting At Gaza's Al-Shifa Hospital: What We Know. Barron's. 2024-03-21 [2024-03-22]. (原始內容存檔於2024-04-16).
- ^ Hospitals have special protection under the rules of war. Why are they in the crosshairs in Gaza?. AP News. 11 November 2023 [19 November 2023]. (原始內容存檔於13 November 2023).
- ^ WHO leads very high-risk joint humanitarian mission to Al-Shifa Hospital in Gaza. www.who.int. [20 November 2023]. (原始內容存檔於20 November 2023).
- ^ Israel says Hamas is using Gaza's biggest hospital for cover. Hundreds of people are trapped inside. AP News. 13 November 2023 [14 November 2023]. (原始內容存檔於24 November 2023).
- ^ Hunnicutt, Trevor. White House says it has evidence Hamas using Al Shifa hospital to run military actions. Reuters. 14 November 2023. (原始內容存檔於14 November 2023).
- ^ Abu Azzoum, Tareq. Israeli military preparing to storm al-Shifa Hospital. Al Jazeera. [15 November 2023]. (原始內容存檔於23 December 2023).
- ^ Al-Mughrabi, Nidal; Al-Mughrabi, Nidal. Hamas command centre, weapons found at Gaza hospital, Israeli military says. Reuters. 15 November 2023 [15 November 2023]. (原始內容存檔於15 November 2023).
- ^ IDF evidence so far falls well short of al-Shifa hospital being Hamas HQ. The Guardian. 17 November 2023 [18 November 2023]. (原始內容存檔於18 November 2023).
- ^ Tanno, Sophie; Alkhshali, Hamdi; Liebermann, Oren. What we know about what Israel says it has found at Al-Shifa. CNN. 20 November 2023 [3 March 2024]. (原始內容存檔於2023-12-04).
- ^ Information missteps have led to questions about Israel's credibility. NBC News. 18 November 2023 [19 November 2023]. (原始內容存檔於19 November 2023).
- ^ WATCH: Information warfare – Israel accused of fabricating evidence. Al Jazeera. [23 November 2023]. (原始內容存檔於23 December 2023).
- ^ The Hamas tunnels under Shifa Hospital, according to Israel. Reuters. 22 November 2023 [23 November 2023]. (原始內容存檔於22 November 2023).
- ^ Inside Israel's Campaign to Prove a Gaza Hospital Was a Hamas Command Center. The Wall Street Journal. 22 November 2023 [1 December 2023]. (原始內容存檔於5 December 2023).
- ^ Israel arrests Gaza hospital director and bombs 300 targets amid truce delay. The Guardian. 23 November 2023 [1 December 2023]. (原始內容存檔於4 December 2023).
- ^ Sabbagh, Dan. Israeli army says footage shows foreign hostages inside Gaza's al-Shifa hospital. The Guardian. 20 November 2023 [20 November 2023]. (原始內容存檔於20 November 2023).
- ^ Loveluck, Louisa; Hill, Evan; Baran, Jonathan; Ley, Jarrett; Nakashima, Ellen. The case of al-Shifa: Investigating the assault on Gaza's largest hospital. Washington Post. December 21, 2023 [December 21, 2023]. (原始內容存檔於21 December 2023).
- ^ Barnes, Julian E. Hamas Used Gaza Hospital as a Command Center, U.S. Intelligence Says. The New York Times. 2 January 2024 [4 January 2024]. (原始內容存檔於2024-07-09).
- ^ Victor, Daniel. Israel says it dismantled a Hamas-built tunnel under a Gaza hospital.. The New York Times. 3 January 2024 [4 January 2024]. (原始內容存檔於2024-04-04).
- ^ U.S.'confident' that Hamas used al-Shifa Hospital as command center. WAPO. 3 January 2024 [2024-03-03]. (原始內容存檔於2024-01-03).
While U.S. officials say the intelligence community has 「high confidence」 in its assessment of al-Shifa’s use by Hamas, they have not publicly released visual or audio evidence. The IDF’s claims have also been challenged by a lack of conclusive proof.
- ^ Liebermann, Alex Marquardt, Oren. US doubles down on assessment Hamas used Gaza hospital as command hub | CNN Politics. CNN. January 3, 2024 [2024-03-03]. (原始內容存檔於2024-06-01).
Neither Israel nor the US have published evidence that fully matches up with the claims
- ^ Srivastava, Mehul; Schwartz, Felicia. Israeli forces advance in Gaza City as Benjamin Netanyahu resists ceasefire calls. Financial Times. [19 November 2023]. (原始內容存檔於19 November 2023).
- ^ Raine, Andrew. Israel launches military operation inside Gaza's Al-Shifa Hospital. CNN. 15 November 2023 [19 November 2023]. (原始內容存檔於19 November 2023).
- ^ Biden Backs Israel's Hospital Raid, Hopeful on Hostage Release. Bloomberg. 16 November 2023 [19 November 2023]. (原始內容存檔於17 November 2023) –透過www.bloomberg.com.
- ^ Wintour, Patrick. Israel faces wave of international condemnation over hospital raid. The Guardian. 15 November 2023 [19 November 2023]. (原始內容存檔於19 November 2023).
- ^ Shortell, Andrew Carey, David. UN High Commissioner for Human Rights calls for independent investigation into Al-Shifa hospitals claims. CNN. 17 November 2023 [17 November 2023]. (原始內容存檔於17 November 2023).
- ^ Taub, Amanda. How International Law Views Military Action at a Hospital. The New York Times. 16 November 2023 [17 November 2023]. (原始內容存檔於17 November 2023) –透過NYTimes.com.
- ^ Scahill, Jeremy. Al-Shifa Hospital, Hamas's Tunnels, and Israeli Propaganda. The Intercept. 21 November 2023 [24 November 2023]. (原始內容存檔於6 December 2023).
- ^ Sinmaz, Emine; Burke, Jason. Israeli soldiers raid al-Shifa hospital in escalation of Gaza offensive. the Guardian. 15 November 2023 [24 November 2023]. (原始內容存檔於24 November 2023).
- ^ Israel launches night raid on Gaza al-Shifa hospital. BBC News. 2024-03-18 [2024-03-18]. (原始內容存檔於2024-04-03) (英國英語).
- ^ Soldier killed as IDF raids Gaza City's Shifa Hospital, battles Hamas gunmen inside. The Times of Israel. 18 March 2024 [18 March 2024]. (原始內容存檔於2024-04-01).
- ^ Styllis, George. Israel-Hamas war latest: Senior Hamas terrorist 'killed in Al Shifa raid'. The Telegraph. 2024-03-18 [2024-03-18]. ISSN 0307-1235. (原始內容存檔於2024-04-07) (英國英語).
- ^ Israeli military says it killed 90 gunmen at Gaza's Al Shifa hospital. Reuters. 20 March 2024 [20 March 2024].
- ^ IDF says it killed 90 "terrorists" around Al-Shifa as doctors say men forced to strip outside hospital. CNN. 2024-03-20 [2024-03-20]. (原始內容存檔於2024-04-08) (英語).
- ^ Beaumont, Peter. Heavy fighting reported around Gaza’s al-Shifa and Nasser hospitals. The Guardian. 2024-03-28 [2024-03-29].
- ^ 43.0 43.1 Nidal Al-Mughrabi, Bassam Masoud. Battles rage around Gaza's Al Shifa hospital, Israel says 170 gunmen dead. Reuters. 2024-03-23 [2024-03-24].
- ^ Israel-Hamas war: U.S. submits draft U.N. resolution calling for immediate Gaza cease-fire. NBC News. 2024-03-21 [2024-03-22]. (原始內容存檔於2024-05-11).
- ^ 以色列对加沙战争的今日发展:向希法医院发出疏散令. Al Jazeera. 2024-03-21 [2024-03-22]. (原始內容存檔於2024-03-24) (中文).
- ^ 哈马斯:以军在希法医院的袭击已致13名病人死亡. 新浪軍事_手機新浪網. 2024-03-22 [2024-03-22]. (原始內容存檔於2024-03-22) (中文).
- ^ Israel’s war on Gaza: List of key events, day 169. Al Jazeera. 2024-03-23 [2024-03-24]. (原始內容存檔於2024-05-16).
- ^ 世界卫生组织总干事谭德塞:已失去与希法医院的联系_手机网易网. 譚德塞_手機網易網. 2024-03-22 [2024-03-22]. (原始內容存檔於2024-03-22).
- ^ 以色列军方宣布打死两名哈马斯高级领导人. 聯合早報. 2024-03-31 [2024-03-31]. (原始內容存檔於2024-04-02) (中文).
- ^ 世卫组织:以色列军队已摧毁加沙希法医院-新华网. 新華網_讓新聞離你更近. 2024-04-03 [2024-04-03]. (原始內容存檔於2024-04-14) (中文).